Fit between leadership type and strategic and organisational context
To drive growth and create value in private equity-backed companies, a different leadership profile is required depending on the development stage the company is at. From our research and experience, two distinct CEO types have emerged, each of which brings value in the right organisational context. For sustainable growth and scale, a mix of characteristics from each type is essential.
Two CEO archetypes in PE
In collaboration with Vlerick Business School, we conducted an in-company project focusing on Belgian private equity (PE). As part of our study, key decision-makers of Belgian PE funds and investors were asked to reflect on the most impactful CEOs they had worked with. It became clear that they distinguish two CEO archetypes: the entrepreneur-founder and the professional manager.
Although both CEO types will drive value creation in PE-backed companies, their impact depends heavily on the development stage and the strategic needs of the company. An important side note is that all interviewees highlighted that ranking CEOs is not straightforward, as success often depends on context.
“Our experience shows that while entrepreneur-founders are often skilled at setting up a business from scratch, other competencies are expected in the subsequent growth phases of the company, which are more about professionalising the organisation and processes”, explains Ebbinge Belgium Director Lisa Colpaert.
Entrepreneur-founder versus professional manager
Entrepreneur-founder
Charisma, hands-on involvement, strong technical expertise, and a passion for the sector are notable characteristics of the entrepreneur-founder. Founders are often emotionally involved and focus on personal relationships. In our research, investors have mentioned that the most impactful entrepreneur-founders are self-aware, know their own vulnerabilities and seek dialogue and external input.
Other common entrepreneur-founder traits include:
- Visionary
- Persistent
- Communicative
- Leading by doing
- Pioneering innovation
- Driven
- Energetic
- Able to inspire
A common pitfall for this CEO type is the risk of becoming overambitious. In this case, a robust framework and sounding board are essential to maintain focus. Also, entrepreneur-founders often have strong personalities, which can be challenging to deal with for investors. At the same time, some entrepreneurs struggle to operate within a PE structure, which can hinder growth or collaboration.
Lisa Colpaert confirms: “Characteristics that are beneficial to build a business, such as decisiveness, firm positioning, a strong drive and a desire to prove oneself, can be counterproductive in a later phase of professionalisation, when the CEO is expected to delegate certain tasks and know his/her own strengths and weaknesses.”
Professional manager
External leaders typically bring structure and processes through professional experience. They are often appointed to take the next step in terms of structure, growth and scale. Very often, having sector experience is decisive in selecting an external CEO. However, understanding the business model, the dynamics of B2B or B2C settings and the distribution channels is more important than in-depth product knowledge.
In contrast to entrepreneur-founders who are often self-made leaders, externally appointed CEOs are usually trained in economics or business administration. They often hold a master’s degree or MBA, and their career paths prepare them for leading complex organisations. For investors, prior C-level experience is an essential element in the selection process.
Additionally, to drive value in PE, professional managers:
- Guide from a high-level perspective
- Develop a clear strategic direction
- Build competent teams
- Elevate existing talent
- Streamline processes and operations
- Expand market reach
External leaders who combine professional acumen with trust in lower management and respect for the existing entrepreneurial culture, are a strong set up for success.
The right leadership type at the right time
As both CEO archetypes bring specific competencies to a company, they play a pivotal role in value creation, provided they are supported by the right organisational context. Founders benefit from a complementary structure and governance, while professional managers thrive when embedded in a strong company culture and entrepreneurial environment.
Regardless of the CEO type, working in a PE-backed company implies that the leader must collaborate with shareholders, regularly and openly communicate with investors and ensure everyone is aligned on key priorities and exit expectations. Managing director at Ebbinge Belgium Rakhal Van Orshoven: “Often, upon the entrance of private equity and growth into a new company phase, the founder remains in his/her position as CEO but struggles with the new set-up. Reporting to shareholders, chairing meetings and following procedures are less energising for many founders than seeking new customers or launching a new concept on the market.”
In this regard, the arrival of a professional manager can significantly boost performance, provided the transition takes place at the right time. “It is not easy for an entrepreneur-founder to determine when his own capabilities and strengths have brought an organisation to its peak and when it is time to pass on the role of CEO to an external leader”, says Ebbinge Director Laurence Dewaele. However, externally appointed CEOs need to be agile, pragmatic and able to deal with the entrepreneurial drive within a PE-backed company.
The interviewees confirmed that combining entrepreneurship and innovation with professional stability and scalability often determines success and leads to sustained operational performance. The challenge lies in deploying the right leadership type at the right time.
At Ebbinge, we understand the high expectations placed on CEOs in PE-backed companies. A CEO needs to be hands-on and at the heart of the organisation, while also able to discuss figures, challenges, opportunities and long-term strategy in the boardroom. This hybrid role requires leaders who can operate in the day-to-day business and set the future direction without becoming overly absorbed in either.